Home > What's happening in other states and countries

Sustainability a major focus in other states

Carol Savonen

Lots of places around the country are wrestling with sustainability issues. Here are a few examples:
New York protecting water, livelihoods

New York City (NYC) and rural upstate New York seem unlikely places where urban and rural people would join together to work for sustainability. There is a long history of strong differences and, at times, animosity between NYC and the communities in upstate New York. But residents of these areas have come together on behalf of clean city water and a sustainable rural working and natural landscape in upstate New York. Everyone is benefiting.

The 8 million people in New York City are lucky to have some of the cleanest municipal water in the world. Most of it comes from a 1,600 square mile watershed in the Catskill Mountains, 125 miles to the north. This watershed is a patchwork of mountains, forests, small towns and family farms—a working landscape.

In 1990, trouble loomed. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) mandated that all public supplies of surface water be filtered for microbes. New York State found it would need to spend $4 to $6 billion to build filtering facilities.

After years of conflict and negotiations, NYC and more than 30 watershed communities came up with the "New York City Watershed Agreement." The plan will sustain the rural residents, their landscape and way of life while protecting the quality of New York’s water supply without filtration, saving the city millions of dollars.

With the plan, the City is freed from filtering water from the Catskill watershed, provided it meets 66 EPA "filtration avoidance criteria." In other words, if the water stays clean, it doesn’t have to be filtered.

The Catskills communities and landowners are required to closely regulate development and resource use to protect water quality. In return, they receive millions of dollars to help pay for programs to protect water quality and land use.

For example, New York City will spend $550 million to improve water quality including upgrading aging sewage treatment plants and replacing failing septic systems in the Catskill watershed area. Dairy farmers and foresters will be trained to protect water quality.

Another $666 million is allocated for conservation easements and partnership programs to protect forest lands. The State of New York is contributing funds in some of these efforts.

"It’s always easier to perpetuate an ‘Us’ versus ‘Them’ mentality," said Alan White, forest program manager for the Watershed Agricultural Council and administrator of the Agreement’s farm and forest practices. "But this is really a ‘We.’ It is their watershed, but it is our livelihood."

Other notable sustainability efforts include:

Sitka diversifying economy

Sitka, Alaska’s largest employer, the Alaska Pulp paper mill closed in the early 1990s. Local officials feared the worst, anticipating an economic collapse and high unemployment. They searched for another major employer.

Citizens grouped together to develop an economy that was more diverse while protecting the environment. Rather than be dependent on one large business like Alaska Pulp again, they wanted to encourage more small "forest-related, not timber dependent" industries. They called for an array of businesses and jobs that utilized sustainable forestry practices, a value-added, environmentally sound wood products industry. And they wanted to protect areas important for the salmon fishery and native Americans depending on a subsistence way of life.

Today in Sitka, the grassroots citizen vision is coming alive. Dependence on timber has declined. Other economic areas are expanding. Tourism, small business, fisheries and health care are growing. The air and water are cleaner. And Sitka is prospering in a more sustainable manner.

Santa Monica launching Sustainable City program

Santa Monica, a city of about 90,000 on the southern California coast, is known for its "Sustainable City" program founded in the early 1990s. The underlying premise of this effort is to address root causes of problems rather than treat symptoms.

Santa Monica’s goals involve resource conservation, pollution prevention, public health protection and community and economic development. Rather than have vaguely worded "feel good" goals, the city tried to write measurable goals, including:

Santa Monica has made significant progress towards meeting goals in 9 of 16 categories in the past decade. Where goals are not easily measurable, they are revised or revamped with considerable citizen and business input.


For more on this topic, visit: